Tomcat is very slow when uploading files on localhost with HTTPS

up vote
0
down vote

favorite

Host1:

  IP: 192.168.9.13

  VIP: 192.168.9.12

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Host2:

  IP: 192.168.9.14

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Tomcat:

  Http Port: 8080

  Https Port: 8124

Nginx:

  Https Port: 8443

nginx upstream use ip_hash

it is very slow when nginx and tomcat is same host, like this:

Client-----(https)----->Nginx-----(https)----->Tomcat

                    192.168.9.13            192.168.9.13

So, skip nginx to test upload file

Host1 192.168.9.13:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.007s

sys     0m0.028s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.023s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    4m18.691s

user    0m0.285s

sys     0m0.067s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.011s

sys     0m0.022s

Host2 192.168.9.14:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.009s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.025s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.010s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    4m32.329s

user    0m0.290s

sys     0m0.081s

According to the results, when Client or proxy is same host with tomcat server and tomcat use SSL, uploading file is very slow.

How can i to solve this problem?

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

You may have an slow SSL handshake. Capture packets with Wireshark and troubleshoot that.
– Luis Muñoz
Nov 8 at 15:09

add a comment |

up vote
0
down vote

favorite

Tomcat is very slow when uploading files on localhost with HTTPS

Host1:

  IP: 192.168.9.13

  VIP: 192.168.9.12

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Host2:

  IP: 192.168.9.14

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Tomcat:

  Http Port: 8080

  Https Port: 8124

Nginx:

  Https Port: 8443

nginx upstream use ip_hash

it is very slow when nginx and tomcat is same host, like this:

Client-----(https)----->Nginx-----(https)----->Tomcat

                    192.168.9.13            192.168.9.13

So, skip nginx to test upload file

Host1 192.168.9.13:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.007s

sys     0m0.028s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.023s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    4m18.691s

user    0m0.285s

sys     0m0.067s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.011s

sys     0m0.022s

Host2 192.168.9.14:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.009s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.025s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.010s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    4m32.329s

user    0m0.290s

sys     0m0.081s

According to the results, when Client or proxy is same host with tomcat server and tomcat use SSL, uploading file is very slow.

How can i to solve this problem?

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

You may have an slow SSL handshake. Capture packets with Wireshark and troubleshoot that.
– Luis Muñoz
Nov 8 at 15:09

add a comment |

up vote
0
down vote

favorite

Tomcat is very slow when uploading files on localhost with HTTPS

Host1:

  IP: 192.168.9.13

  VIP: 192.168.9.12

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Host2:

  IP: 192.168.9.14

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Tomcat:

  Http Port: 8080

  Https Port: 8124

Nginx:

  Https Port: 8443

nginx upstream use ip_hash

it is very slow when nginx and tomcat is same host, like this:

Client-----(https)----->Nginx-----(https)----->Tomcat

                    192.168.9.13            192.168.9.13

So, skip nginx to test upload file

Host1 192.168.9.13:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.007s

sys     0m0.028s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.023s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    4m18.691s

user    0m0.285s

sys     0m0.067s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.011s

sys     0m0.022s

Host2 192.168.9.14:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.009s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.025s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.010s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    4m32.329s

user    0m0.290s

sys     0m0.081s

According to the results, when Client or proxy is same host with tomcat server and tomcat use SSL, uploading file is very slow.

How can i to solve this problem?

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

Tomcat is very slow when uploading files on localhost with HTTPS

Host1:

  IP: 192.168.9.13

  VIP: 192.168.9.12

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Host2:

  IP: 192.168.9.14

  Service: nginx+keepalived,tomcat

Tomcat:

  Http Port: 8080

  Https Port: 8124

Nginx:

  Https Port: 8443

nginx upstream use ip_hash

it is very slow when nginx and tomcat is same host, like this:

Client-----(https)----->Nginx-----(https)----->Tomcat

                    192.168.9.13            192.168.9.13

So, skip nginx to test upload file

Host1 192.168.9.13:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.007s

sys     0m0.028s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.023s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    4m18.691s

user    0m0.285s

sys     0m0.067s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.011s

sys     0m0.022s

Host2 192.168.9.14:

HTTP request:

$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.009s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8080/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.013s

sys     0m0.025s



HTTPS request

$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.13:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 9035cf1720554bb7a912fb208ebc4c1c"

real    0m0.430s

user    0m0.010s

sys     0m0.027s



$ time curl -k -X POST http://192.168.9.14:8124/secwechat/admin/app/upload -F "apk=@/home/temp/QQ_7.6.3.apk" -H "token: 25f3ad9323744c7aab00f53950369f0c"

real    4m32.329s

user    0m0.290s

sys     0m0.081s

According to the results, when Client or proxy is same host with tomcat server and tomcat use SSL, uploading file is very slow.

How can i to solve this problem?

performance tomcat https localhost

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

asked Nov 8 at 8:26

21 BH4CXJ

New contributor

21 BH4CXJ is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.

You may have an slow SSL handshake. Capture packets with Wireshark and troubleshoot that.
– Luis Muñoz
Nov 8 at 15:09

add a comment |

You may have an slow SSL handshake. Capture packets with Wireshark and troubleshoot that.
– Luis Muñoz
Nov 8 at 15:09

You may have an slow SSL handshake. Capture packets with Wireshark and troubleshoot that.
– Luis Muñoz
Nov 8 at 15:09

add a comment |

active

oldest

votes

Your Answer

StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function () {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function () {
StackExchange.snippets.init();
});
});
}, "code-snippets");

StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "1"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});

}
});

21 BH4CXJ is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.

draft saved

draft discarded

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53203868%2ftomcat-is-very-slow-when-uploading-files-on-localhost-with-https%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest

Name

active

oldest

votes

21 BH4CXJ is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.

draft saved

draft discarded

21 BH4CXJ is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.

draft saved

draft discarded

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Name

This page is only for reference, If you need detailed information, please check here

搜尋此網誌

Xtykutl